மார்ச்சு 25, 2023 இதழ்
தமிழ் வார இதழ்

Recalling Adv. Lily Thomas, Best Courtroom’s senior very woman suggest

வழக்கறிஞர் ராஜாசுந்தர் ராமன்

Feb 10, 2024

Supreme Courtroom advocate Lily Thomas, accountable for striking down from Part 8(4) of one’s Signal of those Work, 1951 so you’re able to disqualify good legislator quickly whenever convicted for a few or a great deal more years’ prison, has gone by aside from the ages of 91 in early hours out of within Maximum Hospital inside The newest Delhi’s Patparganj.

Created inside Kottayam, Kerala, Lily Thomas registered Madras Higher Judge for the 1955 and later went on to become the basic woman to-do the latest LLM way from Madras School. She is actually the initial lady from inside the India so you’re able to qualify for an LLM studies .

Hitting down out of Part 8(4) of one’s Symbolization of those Act, 1951

Inside 2013, in the age of 85, she acquired an excellent landmark judgement inside the Basant Ku) seven SCC 653, below and therefore members of India’s Parliament and members of state legislative regulators, found guilty from a criminal activity or perhaps in prison, turned ineligible to operate to possess elections or hold a chosen seat. Before view, people in Parliament who had been found guilty but got filed an attraction may go about their typical business, in addition to are decided on and you will carrying chair.

Lily Thomas, and additionally advocate Satya Narain Shukla had profession good Writ petition on Supreme Legal for the 2005, difficult Point 8(4) of your own Logo of the people Operate hence handles a found guilty lawmakers against disqualification on to the floor out of pendency out of notice facing the belief throughout the higher courts. Into , a bench out of A good K Patnaik and S J Mukhopadhaya, JJ kept you to,

“Parliament had no capability to enact sub-section (4) regarding Point 8 of one’s Work and you can appropriately sub-area (4) of Part 8 of one’s Work try ultra vires this new Structure”

“if any seated Member of Parliament otherwise a state Legislature is actually found guilty of every of the offences mentioned for the sub-areas (1), (2) and you may (3) off Area 8 of your Operate and also by virtue of these conviction and you will/or sentence suffers the disqualifications stated during the sub-parts (1), (2) and you will (3) from Area 8 of Work adopting the pronouncement for the judgment, his subscription away from Parliament or perhaps the Condition Legislature, once the circumstances can be, may not be spared of the sub-part (4) out of Part 8 of Operate and that i have from this view announced because the super vires brand new Composition in spite of he files new interest or change up against the conviction and/or sentence.”

Conversion for bigamy

Inside the Lily Thomas v. Connection out-of Asia, (2000) 6 SCC 224, Lily had filed the newest petition regarding Best Legal into the updates of the earlier relationships out of a situation whenever a non-Muslim will get converted to brand new ‘Muslim’ trust without the actual transform otherwise belief without divorcing very first partner. For the , new workbench from S. Saghir Ahmed and you may RP Sethi, JJ kept you to changes out-of faith cannot melt the marriage performed beneath the Hindu Matrimony Act between one or two Hindus . They said,

“Apostasy will not provide an-end the fresh new municipal debt otherwise the fresh matrimonial thread, however, apostasy are a ground to possess separation and divorce less than Section 13 while the and additionally a ground getting judicial break up under Area ten of your Hindu y. Once we have observed above, the fresh new Hindu y”. A second relationships, when you look at the lifetime of the newest spouse, might be gap lower than Sections 11 and 17, and being an offense.”

The newest Courtroom had next held you to simple conversion process will not give in order to a conclusion the new marital ties except if a beneficial decree to possess divorce thereon ground try extracted from the legal . Till an excellent decree are passed, the wedding subsists. Other matrimony, in the subsistence of your own first relationship would create an offense under Section 494 realize which have Area 17 of the Hindu Relationship Operate, 1955 and person, regardless of their transformation to a different faith, could be prone to getting charged to your offence regarding bigamy.

Petition challenging brand new legitimacy of the ‘Recommend with the Record’ system

Lily Thomas is actually among the first supporters to help you file an effective petition regarding Supreme Court challenging the fresh legitimacy of your own ‘Endorse towards Record’ system with the 14 January 1964. When you look at the For the re also Lily Isabel Thomas, Heavens 1964 Sc 855, she got argued one to due to the fact a supporter entitled to teaching when you look at the that it Court, she is actually titled at the time of right not only so you’re able to plead however, in order to operate, and this the guidelines of https://internationalwomen.net/tr/blog/ukrayna-tanisma-siteleri/ this Legal hence suggest certificates just before she will be allowed to act have been ergo incorrect. She, hence, needed you to Code sixteen(1) away from Order IV of one’s Ultimate Legal Legislation due to the fact revised when you look at the 1962 which has it drug of certification getting announced super vires. In the event her petition were not successful but it flat opportinity for even more petitions which were filed in connection with this plus the topic of your AOR program has been contended many time from the time.

  • Simply click to share towards the LinkedIn (Reveals during the the newest windows)
  • Simply click to share toward WhatsApp (Opens up during the the fresh window)
  • Much more
  • Mouse click in order to current email address a relationship to a buddy (Opens within the the latest screen)
  • Simply click to share with you on the Telegram (Reveals from inside the brand new screen)
  • Simply click to share towards Tumblr (Opens during the the latest screen)
  • Click to share with you for the Pouch (Reveals in the the latest windows)
  • Mouse click to share for the Skype (Reveals into the the fresh new windows)

வழக்கறிஞர் ராஜாசுந்தர் ராமன்

இவரது மற்ற கட்டுரைகளைக் காண இங்கே சொடுக்குங்கள்.

கருத்துக்கள் பதிவாகவில்லை- “Recalling Adv. Lily Thomas, Best Courtroom’s senior very woman suggest”

அதிகம் படித்தது